Differences Between an Agile Coach and a Scrum Master

When organizations decide to switch from traditional waterfall software development to Agile methodology, they often wonder about the distinction between a scrum master and an agile coach. However, transitioning to a new methodology can be challenging, and organizations must grasp the distinction between these two roles during this sensitive phase.

To put it simply, the contrast between a scrum master and an agile coach can be seen as a matter of scale or level, and consequently, their respective responsibilities. The role of a scrum master centers on coaching the team, while the role of an agile coach centers on coaching the entire organization.

When does an organization face a Scrum Master vs Agile Coach scenario?

Scrum is known in the industry as being “easy to understand but difficult to master.” Although the Scrum framework is a concise 14-page document, comprehensively grasping the essence of those pages is no easy feat. That’s why, when an organization is moving towards adopting the Agile methodology, it requires the expertise of an experienced professional with in-depth knowledge of Agile principles.

At this critical moment, the organization can greatly benefit from having both a Scrum Master and an Agile Coach on board. The success of the organization’s goal to become “Agile” is determined by the relationship and cooperation between these two roles, which has been a long-standing debate of Scrum Master versus Agile Coach.

Here are some of the reasons why an organization may require competent Scrum Masters and Agile Coaches during a challenging, intricate, and delicate transition:

• A mere reading of the Scrum Guide does not produce a Scrum Master. It requires patient and sincere practice and years of experience rooted in solid knowledge of the Agile methodology.
• To implement Agile means to move to a new internal landscape which is often unknown. Organizations need experts who can help teams unlearn their deeply ingrained old belief systems and work patterns.
• It is of paramount importance to have an experienced professional who can guide the team through this transition using providing solid support and removing inevitable obstacles at the enterprise level. Normally, such a role of the guide is called Agile Coach.
• The same needs to be done by the scrum master as well. However, her responsibility is much more concentrated at the team level than at the organizational level.
• During the Agile transformation, an organization needs to have adequate resources that help it at both micro and macro levels. A Scrum Master and Agile Coach are the names of such resources that need to be utilized wisely and intelligently.
• Scrum Master vs Agile Coach then is not about exclusion but the inclusion of two similar yet distinct professionals into the integrated system of agile development.

Let’s examine the roles and responsibilities of these resources, and how they can assist organizations in developing high-performing Agile teams to enhance their business value and credibility.

What is a Scrum Master?

In the previous post, we delved into the misunderstandings regarding the responsibilities of a Scrum Master. However, when examining the role of a Scrum Master in the context of the ongoing Scrum Master vs Agile Coach debate, it’s crucial to consider the Scrum Master’s role from this perspective.

Compared to an Agile Coach, a Scrum Master is more closely connected to the team and acts as an internal observer. Conversely, an Agile Coach typically serves as an external observer.

A scrum master is:

• An essential member of the Agile development team.
• A manager was responsible for overseeing the flow of processes within the team.
• A guide who assists the team in adhering to Agile principles.
• A trainer who instructs the team on how to self-manage and self-organize.
• A mentor who aids the team in resolving obstacles encountered during the Agile software development process.

A Scrum Master may have a more limited scope of work than an Agile Coach. However, an experienced and competent Scrum Master can utilize their extensive expertise to implement effective strategies and practices to enhance team performance.

In some cases, an organization may assign additional responsibilities of an Agile Coach to a knowledgeable and experienced Scrum Master, which can be a critical error.

Scrum Master role and responsibilities

During a discussion of Scrum Master vs Agile Coach, the roles and responsibilities of each position can overlap. Essentially, their duties are quite similar. However, there are significant differences in scope.

Here are several responsibilities and roles of a Scrum Master during an organization’s transition to the Agile methodology:

• Imparting knowledge of Scrum theory and practices
• Teaching effective communication skills
• Assisting individual team members in continuously improving their knowledge of Agile and their skills
• Providing valuable assistance in sprint planning and backlog management
• Observing and improving the outcomes of team performance based on her guidance
• Empowering the team to produce high-value increments
• Making the team efficient enough to make and meet commitments.

What Does an Agile Coach Do?

It’s worth noting that there’s no official definition of an Agile Coach in the Scrum Guide. As a result, organizations often equate this role with that of the scrum master. However, it’s important to recognize that the agile coach is not simply a more experienced version of the scrum master. Rather, an agile coach is a distinct and specialized professional with advanced training and skill sets.

Enterprises often confuse the roles of a scrum master and an agile coach, as there is some overlap in their responsibilities. However, it is important to note that an agile coach operates on a broader and more extensive scale than a scrum master. An agile coach possesses the expertise and experience required to enable enterprises to achieve overall agility. In essence, an agile coach can be described as:

• A leader with a progressive perspective
• A supporter to multiple teams as well as to the leadership
• A thorough disciplinarian who motivates teams to continuously and consistently practice and improve
• A mentor
• A facilitator
• A trainer
• A servant leader

For any enterprise that is preparing to adopt the agile methodology, it is crucial to have an agile coach who can motivate teams to develop innovative and valuable solutions with a sense of autonomy and creativity. An agile coach who can effectively balance the roles of mentor, facilitator, and trainer can be a valuable asset to the organization.

Roles and responsibilities of an Agile coach

The responsibilities of an agile coach are more extensive and diverse than those of a scrum master, particularly for those who have advanced beyond the scrum master level. Some common responsibilities of an agile coach include:

• Clearly communicating the agile methodology to the teams as well as to the leadership
• Instilling best practices at the team and organizational level
• Training teams to effectively utilize Agile tools and strategies
• Monitoring and assessing the progress of both teams and the organization as a whole
• Providing support to overcome any obstacles in the path of agile transformation and development process
• Encouraging active participation of all stakeholders and leadership in the agile process
• Advising the leadership in adopting an Agile mindset and culture
• Promoting initial retrospectives and stand-ups.

It’s worth noting that a genuine agile coach would aim to coach the team in a manner that renders their own role unnecessary. As paradoxical as it may sound, this is the ultimate goal for any agile coach.

An indication of effective coaching is when teams no longer need intensive Agile coaching because they have internalized the principles and practices taught by the Agile coach. The Agile coach has successfully enabled the team to surpass their need for external guidance. Such an Agile coach can be seen as a natural progression from an experienced scrum master.

Transformation of a Scrum Master into an Agile Coach

While hiring an Agile Coach directly can provide immediate benefits, it can also undermine the organization’s long-term governance. Therefore, enterprises must appoint scrum masters with the organization’s broader goals, including legacy governance, in mind.

One way to achieve the natural progression from scrum master to agile coach is to provide effective training to scrum masters. Agile coaches can train, develop, and empower strong scrum masters with the necessary skills and knowledge to eventually assume the role of a coach.

Here are some methods that enterprises can use to develop their own agile coaches by growing their scrum masters:

• Providing necessary professional development training and guidance to scrum masters
• Giving scrum masters access and authority to make decisions and take actions for their respective teams
• Empowering scrum masters to focus on team-centric growth strategies by granting them sufficient power.

For a smooth and successful transformation of scrum masters into powerful agile coaches with exceptional coaching skills and expertise, organizations need to offer their full support and willingness.

Scrum Master vs Agile Coach: Key differences

As previously mentioned, the main difference between a scrum master and an agile coach lies in their scope. Now, let’s examine some of the significant areas in which they differ:

Conclusion

While the roles of an agile coach and a scrum master may overlap, they differ significantly in terms of scope and responsibilities. An agile coach operates at a more extensive and broader level, with a focus on helping organizations achieve overall agility. On the other hand, a scrum master’s primary responsibility is to facilitate and coach the scrum team in implementing the agile methodology.

Organizations looking to transition to the agile methodology can benefit greatly from both roles and developing strong scrum masters into agile coaches can help ensure a smooth and effective transition. By providing the necessary professional development training and guidance, as well as empowering scrum masters to make decisions and focus on team-centric growth strategies, organizations can cultivate their own agile coaches with exceptional coaching skills and expertise.

Ultimately, by understanding the differences between an agile coach and a scrum master, organizations can make informed decisions about which role or combination of roles is best suited to their needs, and better equip themselves for success in the ever-evolving world of agile methodology.

Here at CourseMonster, we know how hard it may be to find the right time and funds for training. We provide effective training programs that enable you to select the training option that best meets the demands of your company.

For more information, please get in touch with one of our course advisers today or contact us at training@coursemonster.com